And by the way, you can neither live inside of, nor rent out, your S&P 500 holdings.
Also by the way, you cannot get leverage on the S&P 500 at federally subsidized interest rates.
Gaslighting gaslighting gaslighting.
And by the way, you can neither live inside of, nor rent out, your S&P 500 holdings.
Also by the way, you cannot get leverage on the S&P 500 at federally subsidized interest rates.
Gaslighting gaslighting gaslighting.
There’s almost always leverage in housing. Which worked really poorly for a lot of people in 2008.
It doesn’t matter if you can get housing at say 6% to buy an asset that historically performs poorly. Plenty of people have created rent vs buy calculators. Housing is not a good investment.
Just because wealthy people buy houses doesn’t make it an investment. Wealthy people also buy Ferraris, imagine the cost of those tires compared to a septic tank!
“Global market is up 80x” is literally meaningless without a timeframe.
I’m going to guess that you’re a “real estate investor”/landlord who does okay for themselves, and then complains that you’re just doing okay despite not even having a real job. Besides (gasp!) having to occasionally pay someone to repair your asset – which is actually a distinct job of property management.
But the fact that someone (in fact many people) as unsophisticated as yourself can invest in real estate and avoid destitute poverty is credit to how powerful of an investment vehicle real estate is.
That’s why there’s trillions of dollars in it. You think all these gargantuan real estate firms are doing it for charity? They just love repairing septics? They don’t know they could just open up Robinhood and buy S&P 500?
Of course not. Real estate is one of the largest industries in the country because people can deploy ungodly amounts of capital into it and expect very reasonable risk-adjusted returns across its various cash flow, appreciation, and tax outputs to their portfolio.
Lastly: You've retreated from "real estate is a liability" to "real estate is not currently producing returns above the S&P 500." Completely different claims. Either you're gaslighting people or you're not sophisticated enough to know the difference between them – wrong in either case.
Last 40 years.. the same time frame as every other number i’ve been using.
> availability of cheap leverage is a point against housing as an investment.
It is a point against. If housing is your only source of leverage then you get wiped out in an ‘08 event.
> You think all these gargantuan real estate firms are doing it for charity?
No, they’re doing market research and not blindly buying houses. Just like with cars you can identify which ones will go up in value. However the average car just loses money (but you get to use it).
> Lastly: You've retreated from "real estate is a liability"
I haven’t. The comment was “almost always a liability”. The actual stance i had was it’s not an investment. Just because some of the tails do well doesn’t mean the median did well and that’s what you need for investment advice.
Buying a home that appreciates is nothing like buying a car that appreciates. Again, either you are astoundingly unsophisticated or you're lying through your teeth.
Figuring out which of those is true is not relevant to me nor valuable to other readers on this forum. Have a good weekend!
The claim that "[real estate] is a liability, not an investment" was not made by me. I am refuting it.