The last one (about gum disease) confuses me, because gum disease is really only monitored by checking tip penetration at the gumline on inside and outside surfaces. The in-between teeth areas are not tested at all. I moved to a more aggressive brushing regimen, but still almost no flossing, and my gum health rating scores jumped up. They went from meh to good, but not great.
But not good enough, so the hygenist said "floss more!". Instead, I'm trying a more aggressive mouthwash regimen; mouthwash with fluoride, thymol, and methyl salicylate inhibit bacterial growth (Lysterine with fluoride is the OTC standard to emulate, AFAICT).
Next dental visit I'll have metric feedback on this plan. Yeah, I could floss more, but frankly I hate doing it, and over the long term I tend to skip it, so I'm trying to see what I can do that doesn't require big habit-changing effort.
Now, this is all tangential to dentist legitimacy, except that the hygienists are working on behalf of their dentists, and HOPEFULLY have a consistent messaging at one shop. Shop-to-shop, however, it's clear they are just guessing.