Hacker News Reader

Comment by quacked | Hacker News Reader

The two things that pain me the most are:

(1) Clickable elements no longer visually signifying that they're clickable. Words aren't underlined or written in a special font, sometimes the profile avatar is the clickable link to the profile but sometimes the name is, etc.

(2) No more clean, compact directory trees. We used to have high-contrast compact UI design to look through nested ontologies. Now it's rounded-edges card-based, often without trace lines, and barely ever compact. RIP

View on HN

> No more clean, compact directory trees

Even plain old tables with sortable rearrangeable columns, a staple of all of the traditional desktop UI frameworks, are increasingly falling by the wayside in favor of mobile-style single-column lists with cells consisting of stacks of labels.

It's incredible. And the labels are all turned into pills or chips. Then they don't allow pivoted views of their lists, or if they do allowed pivots it's a visual nightmare.

Your average UX person has no idea what a pivoted table is

Hell your average developer probably doesn't either anymore

This is exhausting with web stuff. Every designer wants flat everything, not even so much as underlining links, let alone enough design to actually make it obvious what's a clickable button.

I think it's this cargo cult attempt to tap into what Apple had pre-2010 on the iPod and first iPhone. They're missing that the design leadership and attention to detail was unparalleled at Apple in that era, so they just flatten everything for a streamlined look and miss every signifier Apple put in its UIs in those days

How about on windows, no visible borders just overlapping off-white

Drives me nuts. It makes everything feel like working on a poorly organized desk.

Another thing I can't stand is that I swear tooltips have decreased in frequency compared to 10 years ago.

Dense UIs are work of art when done right, especially in combination with keyboard centered workflow.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com