Garbage in, garbage out. Modern commercial AIs have eaten a lot of garbage takes peddled by garbage people, both in HN/Reddit/whatever comment sections and dressed up in the language of corporate puffery and academia.
So it's no surprise that they levy this judgement. It's the perfectly correct judgement to levy based upon their inputs.
Heck, plenty of "smart enough their opinion is worth considering" humans have reached the same conclusions just from reading the HN comments.