I love the concept of Reddit AMAs, but have been consistently disappointed by the results. It's not the meme-y questions (I actually find the idea of asking everyone the same inane question oddly interesting) but it seems like interesting questions/content never get surfaced- the interviewee gets absolutely overwhelmed with questions and only answers a few.
I'd prefer a system where a notice goes up that Nate Silver is holding an AMA in 24 hours- people post questions then, and get upvotes/downvotes according to community interest. Then the AMA-er answers them in order until they stop.