> And without NATO support, it is apparent that Russia would have achieved all its military objectives in Ukraine a long time ago.
Let me guess, in three days?The invasion plan crumbled before Ukraine got any foreign aid worth mentioning. The airborne attack of Hostomel airport was successfully repelled, leading to failure to capture Kyiv, leading to failure to decapitate the military command structure, leading to successful coordinated counterattacks on the overstretched invasion force.
Five years and 1.5 million casualties later, Russia has still not managed to recover where it was a few weeks into the war, because it had no realistic plan B after the surprise attack failed.
> That's just normal wartime propaganda - both sides have claimed that civilians are being deliberately "targeted".
Sure. That's why we need to go beyond claims and investigate facts. Russian terror on Ukrainian civilians is widely documented. Eg, in Kherson, where Russian attacks are known as "human safari". UN: "From July 2024, Russian forces have recurrently killed and injured civilians in an area stretching over more than 100 kilometres along the right bank of the Dnipro River in Kherson Province. The drone attacks have been widespread, systematic and conducted as part of a coordinated state policy. /---/ The circumstances of the attacks, the videos, and the explicit threatening text posts demonstrate that Russian armed forces and those supporting them have committed acts or threats of violence for the primary purpose of spreading terror among the civilian population, in violation of international humanitarian law." https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2025/05/un-commissio... > And how many of those from the Global South has offered anything more substantial than words in this war?
Morocco provided tanks, Cambodia sent military specialists to teach demining, Sudan provided mortar ammunition, etc. The "South-vs-North" dichotomy is artificial and mainly lives as yet another Russian propaganda trope. The territorial integrity of sovereign states is such a fundamental principle that it is understood and valued around the world, perhaps even more so in countries that have themselves suffered foreign invasions and colonization and are still recovering from the long-lasting damage. > I obviously have no idea where you plucked those numbers from as I have never read anything similar
Stated by the Russian MoD, widely circulated by all major Russian news outlets, including the state-owned TASS: https://tass.ru/armiya-i-opk/28046063Russian war correspondents openly ridicule such statements, as well as comments like yours, according to which everything in Ukraine has already been blown up five times over. Yet the situation on the ground continues to deteriorate. Russian official recruitment target is 34k soldiers per month, of which about 29k gets filled. Losses have been 37k this month, expected to reach 50k by the end. Territorial gains since the start of the summer, the most advantageous time of the year, have been 180 sq km in total, which is a rounding error in a country of 603 000 sq km. The numbers speak for themselves.
> The only reason Finland retains its independence, government and armed forces is because the pragmatic Finnish leaders capitulated to Russian security concerns, agreeing to all their terms.
Not quite so. In the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact of August 1939, Hitler and Stalin agreed how to divide Eastern Europe. Germany was given a free hand to invade Poland, Russians were expected to attack at the same time from east, but stalled and attacked Poland a few weeks later. After German and Russian forces had met in Poland and held a joint victory parade, Russians set their sights on Finland, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, which Germany had left to them with the pact. Map: https://konzervativizmus.sk/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/36990...All four got ultimatums demanding military bases on their soil to satisfy Russian "security concerns". Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania accepted the demands. Those bases were then used as staging areas for overthrowing national governments and installing puppet regimes loyal to Moscow that unleashed widespread terror against the local population to keep them under control. These oppressive puppet governments survived for half a century, until the end of the USSR. Latvia suffered the most. By the end of the 1980s, Latvians were on the verge of becoming a minority in their own country due to resettlement policies of Russians into Latvia.
Finland was the only one that refused the demands and took up arms and gained a victory by remaining independent instead of following the tragedy of its southern neighbors.
This is why Russian "security concerns" is not a phrase anyone can take seriously in North-Eastern Europe. Everyone's already seen what it means. Talking about Russian "security concerns" in a serious tone is like walking around with a giant "IDIOT" painted on your forehead.
> As for Putin's comment on Poland and Hitler, the context was that Poland had helped Hitler and Germany in the division of Czechoslovakia, but when the Poles refused to give up the Danzig corridor, Hitler, who looked down at the Poles, decided to make an example of them and attack them.
Once again you fail to separate artificial pretexts from the truth. In Hitler's own words: "Danzig is not the subject of the dispute at all. It is a question of expanding our living space in the East and of securing our food supplies, of the settlement of the Baltic problems." (23 May 1939 speech to his top military commanders, later used as key evidence at the Nuremberg trials as a proof of premeditated plan for conquest of Poland.)Hitler was ideologically motivated to conquer Europe using North American westward expansion as a model (mixed with German agrarian romanticism), and what Poland did or didn't do had ultimately little importance. Putin, too, has an ideological worldview that was drilled into him at the KGB: the security apparatus mentality of a totalitarian dictatorship, layered on top of a much broader Russian imperialism, which is rooted in centuries of territorial expansion and the subjugation of other peoples. Russia didn't come to span 11 timezones through acts of kindness, you know.