Hacker News Reader

Comment by Zambyte | Hacker News Reader

I spent the first half of my life in rural America in a town your size. I think I understand.

What I think you don't understand is just how far our infrastructure has crumbled since the introduction of cars. At the risk of mildly doxxing myself, the town that I grew up in is literally the exact same size as yours, and had a train station, that is now unoperated.

https://www.waymarking.com/waymarks/wm10Q2N_Train_Station_Ne...

https://relocationgenius.net/location/New-Woodstock/NY/

We can support transit. We choose not to, because we expect it to have constant occupancy (unlike the roads we maintain and the cars people drive with near zero occupancy most of the time).

View on HN

Are you taking the train to the grocery store?

My area still has functioning train station and it ain't getting me anywhere but to another train station.

This "things can't improve because they are the way they are" attitude is exactly why America is falling behind by so many metrics.

Yes, I would take transit to the grocery store if I needed to get somewhere that I could not reasonably walk or bike. You can actually leave the station once you get there, and even come back later. Perhaps with more than when you arrived.

Of course I would take transit for daily tasks, if it were available, but that just isn't possible everywhere.

I live on a road that started as a literal horse path by the original settlers. I am surrounded by 750k acres of National Forest. I live here to not be close to town. There is no situation in which public transit could reasonably service my area, which is fine! Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

You are literally describing where I grew up. I even linked the location , you can look at it on a map. Please accept that I am not ignorant on this.

There is absolutely no reason there couldn't be a small shuttle that runs every half hour from the closest thing to a "main street" near you, to the nearest town / city that people depend on to survive. It doesn't have to be filled every pass. It can even be empty for most trips, as is evident if you go look out at your road right now, which probably goes most hours entirely unused. What matters is that it is reliable, accessible, and frequent enough to avoid needing to schedule your live around it.

This opens up the world to people who can't or won't drive near you. Which, like it or not, kids, disabled, and elderly people exist. Your town should be accessible to them too, and we (America) have the resources to make it happen.

So if I go to Google Street View for New Woodstock I won't see a single car? I'll only see a single bus servicing the whole community? Or is this just a fantasy you're describing?

Some kids in my area have bus rides of over an hour each way. There are dozens of school buses for the school. It's a huge tax cost.

You are out of your mind if you think this would be acceptable or even feasible for the average person, let alone the disabled or elderly.

23 years ago, I lived in a little apartment that was nice, but nestled in the middle of "Sin City" as my friends called it. They declined to renew my lease, and I figured that was OK, because I was aware that the Light Rail line would be built right next to it, except the apartment would be exactly in the middle between two stations, making it sort of inconvenient.

Fast-forward to 2015, and I was moving in to a new place. It is also between two LRT stations. In fact, the properties right next to the stations are new, and they demand a premium. Nevertheless, the LRT is now quite convenient for me to board. But are there grocery stores?

Well, there's a pan-Asian grocery 2 miles away. There's a Fry's 4 miles away. I don't shop at Fry's. There's a Food City that is 7+ miles away, but I don't shop there, either.

It's really kind of laughable how limited the choices are, in terms of grocery stores right along our LRT line. If I go about a mile and I'm willing to walk (steep incline) there's a Trader Joe's, which is great. I usually do that, but I also take a Waymo home, due to the weight of the burdens.

There's a Whole Foods a few miles away, too. It's possible to take the LRT, transfer to the Street Car, and get dropped off one block away. Then, to go home, I could reverse that. But if I purchased significant groceries, I cannot. The Whole Foods is situated in a multi-story parking garage, and this makes it a veritable nightmare for Waymo or any rideshare pickups. Therefore, Whole Foods is on my "Do Not Shop" list, because I can't bring anything home. (Oh, and on delivery they will send me expired foods.)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com