Hacker News Reader

While I like the analogy, I'm not sure it holds how I think of AI. I'd do woodworking because I want better quality for less money, and that's why I use AI now. "Hand crafting" code might be fun but it doesn't get you it cheaper or better anymore IMHO

View on HN

Better quality for less money? No. You do woodworking (if in fact you do) because you enjoy it. The time spent making a decent piece of furniture you could work at McDonald’s and buy a nicer piece in less time it takes to master woodworking.

So, don’t kid yourself! You enjoy it, and if you’ve mastered the skill then naturally you can save money over time. But I’d wager you spend more in hours mastering the skill than if you were to buy a couple pieces of furniture. ;)

It most certainly gets you better. Arguably not cheaper, though that depends on whether you're writing the code yourself (in which case it's cheaper) or hiring it out (in which case it's more expensive). But it's definitely better, because LLMs still are worse than humans at programming.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com