Unfortunately, those same studies (you're referencing a Dun & Bradstreet study with that 18%) show that debit cards with a VISA/MasterCard logo on them increase spending just as much. It's all about the lack of transparency, i.e. it hurts less to pay with plastic.
I can't find an actual link to that study, unfortunately, but here's an article based on the info in that DNB study: http://seekingalpha.com/article/20333-guide-to-credit-cards-...