Well, evidently he’s going to kill me without retribution or they’re going to kill me with retribution. The latter scenario leaves society better off. The convex hull of our two killer sets can then leave society through short-term targeted violence and everyone can else can live. It’s not a bad idea. I don’t think the graph goes particularly far to be honest.
Your world is a perfectly coherent world. Under those circumstances, I accept those outcomes.
I would prefer sequestration for murderers, but if it's not available, killing the first unjustified murderer is fine, and if that's not available I accept the convex hull.