C: Not tens of millions. How do you use those cores? They load one byte at a time and it will take 500 cycles to get there. Want a 64 bit address? 4000 cycles for something that happens in less than one cycle on a modern cpu because the cpu can do multiple things at once. Then you can only add and subtract 8 bit numbers.
M: CPUs running in the low megahertz such as a 6510 or 68000 or Z80 and so, on do not take 500 cycles to read a byte from memory. Most 6510 instructions are 3 - 7 or 8 cycles and may cost between 1 and 4 reads or writes. Your statement about 500 cycles only applies to CPUS running at GHZ.
Im not talking about about having thousands of millions of simple 6510 like cpus running at GHZ, im suggesting having them run at their usual speed in the low MHZ, where their clock speed is roughly the same as memory bandwidth.
C: That "local memory" is called cache and it is done with more transistors. What kinds of programs do you think will run on a computer with no main memory? It is literally the only consistent part of computer design over the last 60 years.
m: Sorry for the confusion, im not talking about cache im talking about individual or groups of small 6510s like cpus sharing or having their own memory. Look at the old systems such as consoles. Rather than a unified memory, the SNES for example had main memory for the CPU, some memory for the graphics and the sound chip itself had its own memory. In my suggestion you could repeat the same many many times for many many humble cpus.
C: You can fetch a single byte at 500 Khz. That's about 1.28 million times slower that a modern cpu. Now your 240,000 fpus (11 billion transistors of a modern / 6800 + fpu transistors) are going to lose on memory alone. Don't forget that you still have every floating point number taking 100 - 1000 cycles and your cycles are 5000x slower than a modern cpu.
m: The difference between MHZ and GHZ is 1000x not 1000000x. A 6510 is thousnads NOT millions of times slower compared to a single core belonging to a x86.
> speed difference between 6510 and modern x86
> A modern x86 processor is tens of thousands to millions of times faster in real-world computing throughput than a MOS Technology 6510, depending on workload, vector/SIMD use, and core count.
> Key Differences
> Clock speed: The 6510 (used in the Commodore 64) ran at roughly ~1 MHz (0.985–1.023 MHz), whereas modern x86 CPUs run around 3–5+ GHz—roughly 3,000x to 5,000x as many clock cycles per second.
I thought i said it before but theres nothing wrong with my idea supporting simple slow FPU units.
c: What have I been writing? If you want deeper information go find it, I'm not going to copy and paste entire books to a person who doesn't want to hear that their wacky ideas don't work.
m: You are misunderstanding many fundamental statements and not appreciating the spirit of my suggestion. For example the issue of FPUS i never said my suggestion shouldnt have FPUs im simply saying it could have simple FPUs. Modern cpus have a lot of extras that cost transistors, eg multiple levels of cache, Out of order execution which of course requires register renaming and all the extra copies of stuff. If you reduce things as simple as possible with no caches of any kind, no Oout of order, no renameing of registers, none of all the buffers you save a lot of transistors.
Those transistors mean you can have a lot more cores running.