Conventional advice is to buy a smart TV and never connect it to the internet. Just plug in [device of your choice] to HDMI.
Yes, because the price is not subsidized from the selling of personal information.
> “The business model is shifting away from making money on TV sets and instead to making money on ads and data that is delivered by those TV sets,” said Paul Gray, Omdia’s Research Director, Consumer Electronics and Devices, at last week’s HbbTV Symposium in London.
* https://www.broadbandtvnews.com/2024/11/18/tv-companies-sell...
https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/1wbjk0o/sceptre_tv...
The Amazon and Walmart links given on Sceptre's product pages don't link to any televisions. Example: https://www.sceptre.com/TV/4K-UHD-TV/U515CV-UMRDD-50-4K-UHD-...
No, it's because their target is businesses which aren't so sensitive to price and like the extended warranty that comes with.
...just like "These TVs are recording what you're saying and analyzing what you're watching and sending that data back to HQ." was a persistent myth.
These companies have been demonstrated to give zero shits about your privacy and -at least in the US- won't be meaningfully punished for behaving in profoundly antisocial ways, so the smart move is to expect that they are or very soon will be making full use of the hardware that's installed in that TV that you paid to take home from the store.
I've heard so many people call it a myth. SO many. Even today, folks disbelieve it.
> ...not a single soul has ever proven...
A manufacturer that will do this [0] absolutely has the attitude required to configure their products to autonomously discover and connect to wifi or other data-transmission networks and phone home when that product hasn't been provided with an Internet connection.
To put it another way: If you see a raving guy out on the street who's very obviously crazy and is wildly brandishing a firearm, you don't wait until he squeezes off a round or three before deciding to behave as if he's capable of shooting someone.
I'd love for a TV to include a 4G/5G connection that they pay for; it'll be hacked for free Internet before the first production run leaves the store shelves.
https://partpricecheck.com/parts-lookup/lg-oled65c5aua-oled6...
I opened up my LG TV because I saw it doing aggressive wifi scanning even when the wifi was "disabled" and physically removed the antenna wire and wrapped the whole guts in RF blocking foil.
I’m not sure I believe you? (Not that I can’t believe a company would do something dodgy behind your back, but I just don’t think our phones would go that far off piste - opening a wifi network has battery power implications that I think would have been discovered/widely known before)
Comcast / Xfinity definitely does this. I have gotten many 'suspicious activity' CAPTCHAs on popular websites while using my home internet because of this. The routers provided by Xfinity are very locked down so you can't do anything about it.
Let's not even get into WiFi Motion which uses WiFi to track you inside the house. I'm sure it is enabled by default in most households [1]
I imagine if they were going to strike a deal with the phone companies they’d just embed cell chips in the TVs and connect directly.
I've told myself if they start putting 5G in TVs I would either glue a faraday mesh to the back or open up the TV and ground out the antenna or remove the WiFi chip if possible.
If they would keep the spying to matching my shows with programs that are being aired or on popular streaming services, sports, or whether I mute the commercials, that wouldn't bother me. Screen grabs would , especially if I use it on my computer. But history has shown this starts off benign and eventually devolve into listening to the room at all hours and keeping it forever in a Bluffdale data center because "think of the children" / "national security".
I was more thinking of the discoverability aspect. The phone (presumably) would have to be constantly advertising the availability of a hotspot.
But honestly the bigger thing that makes me not believe it is the scale of conspiracy required. All companies, Apple included, would have to secretly be in on it.
That's a strong statement, what's your source?
Ugh, I was afraid of that kind of thing. The manual for my older LG indicates there's UI option to disable wifi entirely. Of course, it doesn't actually exist.
Scanning neighboring wifi networks does not mean it's connecting to them.
I want to do this for my lg too.
I believe they have a bluetooth antenna and a wifi. Was there just an obvious thing to cut?
also https://www.ifixit.com/Answers/View/539438/Want+to+remove+43...
They have microphones and listen to conversations while transcribing the words to listen for "wake words". THey are in fact always awake, and transcribing the words they hear.
They all send telemetry and usage data and they all scan for devices in your home and SSIDs.
The only difference is that you think you can trust these devices vs the TVs which use ACR.
I dont see much of a difference here.
so, no they are not in fact all sending telemetry and usage data
Samsung QB55C-N 55" UHD 4K HDR Commercial Monitor without Wi-Fi
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1828914-REG/samsung_q...3 HDMI ports. Any downsides using as a TV?
Reposting from nine days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50332351
Maybe gotta find one used from a business offloading their old ones.
I'm not sure they're not doing something else.
Edit: watch the video "Reverse Engineering Proves What We Suspected All Along" on the Low Level YouTube channel for the example.
(Wish Apple had an incredible response to every single question, but while I’m still a fan, not going to use this comment as a plug… A little disappointed)
> Nerd Edition
Ooooh the expansion dropped!!
Sceptre U860CV-UMRD: 4k HDR @ 60 Hz(8 ms), 300 nits LCD(DLED), 3xHDMI 2.0 (HDCP 2.2) ACR, OS: None?
Samsung QB85C-N: 4k HDR @ 75 Hz(10 ms), 350 nits LCD(VA), 3xHDMI 2.0 (HDCP ?) 1xACR, OS: Tizen 7.0, AV1 support
LG 86UR340C9UD: 4k HDR @ 120 Hz (5 ms), 330 nits LCD(DLED), 2xHDMI ? (HDCP 2.0) 1xACR, OS: webOS 6.0
ViewSonic CDE86G3: 4k (not HDR) @ 60 Hz(?? ms), 500 nits LCD(VA), 3xHDMI 2.0 (HCDP 2.2) 1xACR, OS: None?
And, because this is HN, even though it is only 65":
Flanders Scientific: XMP651: 4k HDR @ 60 Hz (?? ms), up to 4000 nits QD-OLED, 1xHDMI ? (no HDCP) 4xSDI, OS: None?
I believe none of these have Wifi. None of them is perfect. Only the Flanders Scientific model has an OLED display, but it is roughly 10x the price of the others (this is a reference monitor, which is very much not targeted at consumers). It also only comes in sizes up to 65" and only has one HDMI port, which does not support HDCP at all. If you only need 55", they have a 2000 nit display (V550) that supports regular HDMI inputs (but is still quite expensive).
Of the remaining displays, the ViewSonic is the brightest, but does not have HDR support. The LG display supports the highest refresh rate and is probably the cheapest, but only has HDCP 2.0 (I think?), and runs webOS, which I view as the least trustworthy of the options. The Samsung display is the only one with built-in AV1 support (if that matters to you). They also have some older models (e.g., BE85FX-H), which may still be available somewhat cheaper, but I can find very little information on them. None of the displays appear to support HDMI 2.1 or 2.2, so 4k HDR is limited 4:2:0 chroma at 60 Hz. The ones labeled "OS: None?" clearly have an OS (the ViewSonic one advertises a 7 second boot time, for example, despite being labeled "OS-Free"), but it does not appear to be any of the major known-problematic ones.
I have no direct experience with any of these, so I cannot prove that they are not still spying on you.
Unfortunately a lot of large displays really aren't safe to open -- you're likely to break the screen doing it. But I have seen some results on LG tvs that have the wireless hardware on a separate removable board that the TV runs fine without.
If the alternative is a commercial signboard display or a reference monitor though one might be better off buying N consumer TVs and accidentally destroying a couple. ... and the question of giving money to companies bundling spyware might be better addressed by spending the price difference funding efforts to stop the practice via other means (e.g. outlawing it... to the extent that its not already unlawful, lobbying state AGs to take action to the extent that it is...).
* https://www.samsung.com/us/business/commercial-tvs/all-comme...
65" VA (not edge-lit, DLED) without any OS (doubt), $1000