Those latitudes are pretty close, but that doesn't tell the whole story.
At noon on the equinox, Amsterdam gets 80% of the sun that NYC does, and Fairbanks gets 56%. But, at noon on the winter solstice, Amsterdam gets 55% of the sun that NYC does, and Fairbanks gets 7% ofthesun NYC gets. So, in terms of insolation above the atmosphere, Fairbanks is dramatically worse than Amsterdam. If the sine of the sun elevation was the whole story, to survive the winter on solar, you'd need 8× the solar panels in Fairbanks you'd need in Amsterdam, which would need less than 2× New York.
In fact, cloud cover is very important, and I think it narrows the gap a bit.