The research does something like this. You run an experiment and show some chemicals are present in low concentration. You say "ah ha, we've shown one step". Those chemicals are now taken off the shelf in high concentration and used in the next experiment, which makes slightly more complex chemicals in low concentration. Repeat this multiple times until done.
Lampooning this, the fictional OoL researcher in the book also demonstrates that monkeys can type out "To be or not to be, that is the question" on a typewriter. He arranges the typewriter with an automatic right margin and lets them type away until he gets a line starting with "T". First letter demonstrated! Now he rereun the experiment, but now with paper the "T" in the first column and margins set to the second column. Repeat this with subsequent letters until the entire sentence is produced. Of course, the monkeys didn't type the sentence, the researcher did.
Getting around the exponential complexity barrier is the whole goddamn point, it's not something to just wave away with a "we don't know" comment.
IMO some fundamentally new idea is needed for OoL.
Not the best analogy.
Lets say you are looking for 'any sentence'. What if you never get the T, you get a G. The sentence is what your looking for, not a specific one. It could be another sentence, but a sentence none the less. Then you can ask, how many typewriters did it take to get the first letter, then how many for the next, (not infinite). Now how likely would this sentence appear in nature if a bunch of chimps were let loose in a typewriter store.
Its funny you are using this as an argument against. When it is actually is the process in Assembly Theory.
"Life As No One Knows It: The Physics of Life's Emergence ". Assembly Theory: A centerpiece of the book is Assembly Theory, which Walker co-developed (with Lee Cronin and collaborators). Assembly theory measures the "assembly index" of an object—quantifying the minimum number of steps and building blocks required to construct it.
But the researcher is performing the selection process for the purposes of the experiment, to speed things up. Evolution functions via natural selection. That's what makes it different from the pure random chance processes.
And "it's not exponential, therefore it's not possible" is?
The general problem here is that handwaving ignores the issue I raised, and those making OoL theories have to address these issues, not require skeptics to disprove their handwaving. Requiring the skeptical to disprove such things is classic crank behavior.
They certainly warrant discussion and investigation.
Handwaving away the possibly infinite nature of the available experimentation space and the anthropic principle is the same failing you're widely accusing others of.
You, elsewhere in the thread: "I expect people to not make declarations about things we don't know."
How do we know that? When did we confirm what came before the Big Bang? How do we know this isn't the sixty trillionth iteration of a 15 billion year process that only just now resulted in life on one of untold trillions of planets to pay notice to it?
Please don't say death implies life. By death you should infer removal from category a la RNA depolymerization, or lipid membrane lysis.
Of course I don't know what the pre-life entities are. But they were surely selected for.
what does accurate mean
> there's no plausible way proposed that can occur without life already existing
Why do you say that. RNA can replicate by templating. obviously replicators came to exist from non replicators. and life from nonlife. what claim are you making? that that isn't selection because you have a definition of selection that excludes that process?
Life has very complicated mechanisms for ensuring very accurate replication of DNA, but of course these mechanisms would not have been available at OoL.
Biochemist and OoL enthusiast here. This is very not true. Evolution happens in even the simplest complex systems. It's very likely a process of matter.
Look up the work of Dr Michael Levin. He shares on YouTube many of his convos with leading thinkers. He's quite prolific lately.
Similarly, when creating single-crystal metal parts (turbine blades) a handful of growing crystals is put through a maze, with only one surviving to continue out into the bulk of the part. One is selected and thrives, the others stop growing after being out-competed for resources/space. It looks and sounds like life but... crystals are a special case imho.
So I strongly dispute your assertion there.
You cannot point out exact steps how we evolved till now yet here we are. "We don't know" is a perfectly fine answer even if it somehow triggers you. Universe is not arranged around such folks, universe doesn't care about some tantrums, universe just is, in ways we still don't fully understand and thats fine.
Who, specifically, is doing this in this thread? People are very clearly discussing hypotheses, possibilities/probabilities, and outstanding questions. No one's claiming "here's the answer".