I know this is common verbiage, but it's frankly sickening. Do they view their targets as people, or are they merely a collection of scalps?
I know this is common verbiage, but it's frankly sickening. Do they view their targets as people, or are they merely a collection of scalps?
This is quite different from Aaron Swartz who wrote a slightly more advanced recursive 'wget'/'curl' to download something he already had access to.
What I am reacting to quite specifically is the notion that "winning" a higher sentence is somehow a goal in and of itself.
Having worked quite closely with the legal community over the last half decade, I have to say that the mercenary attitude many hold continues to jar me.
>Most legal experts agree that, in the long run, the adversary system results in societal benefits that outweigh its inherent shortcomings. By allowing all sides of a controversy to be heard, the system protects against abuse of power, and forces those with the most at stake to focus on the issues in dispute.
(from http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Adversary+Syst...)
Where I'm from the maximum sentence is 15 years in prison.
I know he stole a lot of money but this is compared to people who have destroyed lives, many of whom enjoyed doing so.
I don't think I'll ever agree with this. I have seen this argument brought up times and times again and every time I feel that we miss the point.
Stealing money is bad, yes. Does it deserve a similar amount of time as someone who committed a murder?
Also, nowadays, people who steal money are stealing money from businesses that are protected against those very thieves (Banks, insurances, big commerces). So basically, it's better morally to steal from a bank/insurance than it is to pickpocket since pickpocketing has a direct impact on a single person.
Don't you guys have enough people in jail already?
EDIT: corrected amount of time in comparison to murder.
I agree that 20 years is excessive for Gonzales, but it's not the same as (many) murderers.
If it did, then it definitely deserves as long a sentence as murder. Indeed, an (attempted) financial crime of this magnitude is frequently worse than murder since it (potentially) has similarly devasting effects on a much wider set of victims.
For comparison, this guy[1] shot 77 people, but he was sentenced only "21 years and a minimum of 10 years" and he will spend this period in a luxury prison of Norway.
In the U.S., that same crime would have resulted in a minimum of life in prison, and possibly would have resulted in the death penalty.
They measure their success purely in terms of won cases, unsurprisingly - if you go to certain bars around the temples in London, you will overhear conversations along the lines of "got this guy sent down for 20 years today, don't know if he did it, but who gives a shit, and I'll be a QC in 5 years! Crack open the champagne!". They're not even in it for the money, as the CPS pays abysmally. They'd rather defend, as that pays - and again, on that side of the table, they have absolutely no interest in the innocence or guilt of their client, just in avoiding a conviction.
It's purely mercenary, and their stance is that it's just business as usual and impartiality - but it's a business that can cost innocent people their lives, and let the guilty walk free.
I believe your prosecutors in the US are rather better paid, which sets the incentives for conviction roughly on a par with acquittal.
This is part of what makes them so "good"--by objectifying the target, they are better able to think purely strategically about how to secure a conviction.