I'd say that justifying it as because you can still determine the truthiness of a string is missing the point; defined? (http://ruby-doc.org/docs/keywords/1.9/Object.html#method-i-d...) can return one of a number of string values, or nil, depending on what expression you pass to it. The actual return value can be useful to you depending on what you're doing, or you might be happy enough just accepting that there it returns a value other than nil (which is to say you don't care what it is, just that yes, something is defined which matches the passed expression).