What I like better there:
* Their button has a really sharp glossy look. Yours are nice, but not as nice (that I noticed, at least).
* They have more fonts than you do.
What I like better about yours:
* Lots more control over most of the details. Notably, the custom color gradients.
* The showcase of editable examples. Very nice.
* Less clutter on the page. Though I certainly would not blame you if you put up ads or a tip-me button.
Although I think your extensive options are good, it's sort of a power-user interface. You might consider a simpler interface for visitors who want something very quick and easy. Or, you could expand your gallery of examples, perhaps even add a sidebar of examples to the front page.
All in all, very well done. Congratulations and thank you.