This may seem absurd, but I actually do use two sets of headphones for maximum noise protection. Why go through all this trouble? Sometimes you're forced to work in a noisy environment and there's no way around it. As a bonus, it's great for sleeping or watching movies on a plane.
I got the idea from this HN discussion:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4802118
Things I've tried:
- earphones (J2)
- inner ear phones (X10, e2c)
- noise canceling over ear headphones (QC2)
- earphones / earplug + ear muff (J2 + H10A)
The last option gives the best noise protection. I've experimented a bit, but J2 buds[0] or regular ear plugs are most comfortable with noise protection earmuffs[1] on the outside. The inner ear phones are not comfortable with an additional over ear headphone.
For $30 I can achieve a level of noise isolation where I can't hear myself typing, or someone speaking directly at me 12" away.
[0] J2 ear buds ($8): http://goo.gl/vQZb4
[1] 3M Peltor H10A 105 dBA ear muff($22): http://goo.gl/6P24g