a) write evergreen content that HN users are likely to upvote or read (HN catnip) based on current HN trends
b) fill content with paid referral links
c) post catnip to HN
a) write evergreen content that HN users are likely to upvote or read (HN catnip) based on current HN trends
b) fill content with paid referral links
c) post catnip to HN
I really doubt referly is trying to make revenue by posting on hn. More likely, it is to get feedback on product and design. People post links about their own products all the time, and the community is pretty supportive, generally.
After all, if you wrote a blog engine and blogger with it, and wanted to make a blog post to link to hn, it would probably be with your own blog engine, not Wordpress.
(I do agree that some of their "top 20 lists of random products" were kind of borderline; I'd cut them slack as a startup, particularly since dmor has been super helpful in the startup community (she mentors at 500 Startups, etc.). I don't really like her or Kevin's taste in some products like food, though.)
You are right, we are using HN as a place to test different kinds of content. I hear every negative comment, I also get a lot of emails on both sides, helpful and hateful, and use that to figure out what kind of content is good. What I'm fundamentally interested in is answering is "what is good for X" - where X are all these different categories.
For food, I'd get Jonas or Makitoh from Quora; both are authors working on books, so they would love to self promote.
It might be interesting to not go after big categories like "food" or "photography" but crossover like "food photography". I doubt even the world's number one food stylist or food photographer has too much publicity. There are what, 10 big categories? But then there are at least 100 crossovers, and more if they are more than pair wise (travel food photography)
i.e. -- opinionated and interesting. or, totally bland and impartial and sometimes "wrong" from the consensus, but due to picking different metrics; accuracy within those metrics is always unassailable. The bad case is motortrend, which is just PR + idiocy + pay-for-play.
I guess you could be Edmunds, too (longitundinal research, etc.)
The worst thing would be "these are the top 5 9mm handguns" where you include Sig, Beretta, S&W M&P, Glock, and Hi-Point, due to Hi-Point paying you for associating them with 4 quality manufacturers. I'd have no problem with "these are my favorite guns from my collection" where if you buy any of them, I get affiliate 0.$$, particularly if that part is transparent.
It's even better when you declare that you're donating all the affiliate money to charity (which I did, on my refer.ly experiments, and I think dmor did too).
The big problem with existing media is not hidden commercial bias but just straight incompetence. If giving people 5% sales commissions solves that, that's a net win over keeping them disinterested.
In shoet, I would prefer no monetary incentives to keep the web amateur. I don't want to have to filter every blog post I read through a "Am I being scammed?" filter.
I think there are probably people who write reviews/promote their favorite products at a small scale, but not the larger blogs.
The amounts of money which go to people seem so low as to be pointless (i.e. I'll help my friend move for free, but I'd be insulted if he offered me $5 for 3 hours. However, free pizza would be a plus). I don't know how Referly could turn the money into "free pizza" instead of $5, though. Anyone making "real" money is more likely to go direct.
If the money goes to Referly and/or charities, that removes the bad incentives, too.
Assuming there's full disclosure, one might make the argument that writing on commission would lead an (ethical) author to think even harder about being balanced, since the bias is recorded fact, rather than something the reader has to guess at.
d) figure out what readers want and extend to 1000s of online communities
e) profit
How would you suggest starting a massively distributed publishing business with no ads?
At least I am glad it isn't one of those "my mom started to work from home" ads :)