For example, I don’t necessarily want pure functions by default in my idealised programming model. To me, a pure function is just a special case of a function whose effects are controlled and where the resources the function might interact with are readily identifiable, for which the sets of possible effects and interacting resources happen to be empty.
Put another way, I don’t see anything wrong, or even inferior or undesirable, with performing a quicksort of an array or some fast matrix computations destructively. However, I’d like my language to make sure I couldn’t accidentally try to use the old data again afterwards (including, for example, in other threads running in parallel). I’d like to be sure that just because my algorithm updates one set of data in-place, it doesn’t also draw a window, block to wait for user input, or kick off a background thread that will reformat my hard drive in half an hour. And in the calling code, I’d like to find out very quickly that just because I created and populated an array over here, and then ran a quicksort that changed it over there, and then printed it out down there, nothing else had any chance to modify it in between.
And I’d like to do all of that using syntax that is at least as clean and readable as today’s best languages, please, not the horrors that often seem to result when functional programming languages try to implement equivalent behaviour with realistic heavily structured/monadic values instead of the neat one-integer counter or append-only log that always seems to be used in the tutorial code samples.
I suspect that to do that will require a language that provides dedicated, specialised tools to support the new programming model. Sure, you could probably do this sort of thing using monads in Haskell, just as you could do OOP in C, text processing in C++, or write in a functional style in Python, but the results are clumsy compared to using the right tool for the job. I’m not sure that tool exists yet for the kind of programming models I’d like to use, but that’s where I’m hoping the lessons of today’s functional languages and academic research will bear fruit over time.