In the case of JavaScript libraries virtually everyone has standardized upon jQuery at this point.
In other words, as far as he cares things other than jQuery don't have a right of existence. Although it's very popular it's probably even more arguable if there aren't better JavaScript frameworks than jQuery, compared to whether there are better rendering engines than WebKit.
I believe it comes pretty close to illustrating what I believe is so wrong about his arguments.
jQuery or WebKit being dominant platforms doesn't requite that innovation stop, it gives innovation the ability to explode: When you don't have to work about nit-picky cross-platform capabilities or standardization then you get to focus on performance and building sweet frameworks like Backbone and Angular.
I think that's an easy argument simply by looking at the
numbers
Popular does not imply "better."Given that A is 10-100x more popular than B, what are the odds that B is "better" than A? Slim.
Now, popularity does not imply that something is the best. Often times there is something better that isn't as popular. But generally the popular thing is better than most alternatives.
I don't think he made that point at all. He is merely reflecting on the fact that jQuery has the most market share and by a long way.