Yes, it's a strange day when we move from "cables that work perfectly well BUT the device with the ports they connect to has to be replaced whenever a new technology cames along" to "cables that need to be software upgradable but are far more future proof and capable all the while freeing the device from those concerns".
The stereo beside me has components that span 30 years and uses the same cabling for all components.
I realise someone will come back with "Oh, but DRM, encryption, needing more information about the source and destination"... but I'd counter by pointing out that telecoms cabling works perfectly well for transporting all kinds of things across it. You can put into protocols the things that you need, without having to create hardware problems that require constantly replaced and software upgradeable cabling.
Aren't all problems in computing this way?
>The stereo beside me has components that span 30 years and uses the same cabling for all components.
Yes. And it does just one thing. Output analog electrically encoded sound signals.
Now, call me again when that stereo cabling has to also support: audio out, digital audio out, video out, different resolutions, MIDI out, connecting to medical and scientific devices for control, charging, data backup and sync, ethernet, etc etc...
>I realise someone will come back with "Oh, but DRM, encryption, needing more information about the source and destination"... but I'd counter by pointing out that telecoms cabling works perfectly well for transporting all kinds of things across it.
Only because there is a computer in the other (either an actual PC or a TV, etc) that knows what to expect and how to decode it and show it.
In this case, the computer is inside the cable, so the connected devices don't have to know everything.
All Apple is doing is proprietary lock-in here - it's not more flexible in anyway, where as HDMI is signal compatible with DVI and DisplayPort.
This allows for absolutely ANYTHING, barring bandwidth concerns.
Ubiquitous body computers with skin access ports? We can make an interface for that.
"Quantum broadcast" antenna technology? We can make a dongle for that.
For the record each of these has a purpose and reason. Some were a function of the materials present at the time others due to specific environmental concerns. I would not class any in the realm of "lock-in". Due to the capital intensive nature of the industry they each were good business decisions at the time. It wasn't as easy as buying a $40 plug.
If there weren't the huge installed base of wires in the walls of buildings, we probably would have different standards for patch cables instead of fairly obscenely complex network interfaces.
But with lightning you can design cables which need not use device computing power for all transformations, it is pretty smart, they built this cable for the next decade we will see interesting applications from apple and its partners in coming years
And before than in the days of first fast ethernet implementations there also were incompatibilities of similar type, which is mostly the reason that every managed or even "smart" switch allows you to disable auto negotiation quite prominently in it's configuration interface. Although that was more about software issues than about interoperable implementation being non-practical as is to some extent the case with copper SFP modules.
Bottom line: "I don't know what the next network interface will look like, but it will be called Ethernet and use RJ45 connectors on CatN (for some value of N) twisted pair ..."
Personally, I'm waiting for software-upgradable domestic light switches and mains plugs. Then we're in trouble ...