If you want to respond with anything less than the best possible tools available to ensure you survive the event then you can certainly make that choice. But I couldn't in good faith tell someone else to make that choice. If you're a bystander near a heavily armed criminal the only safe place to be is far away.
Cops certainly do not need to be using 'weapons that belong on the battlefield' as their go-to weapon for any raid unless it is suspected that there may be body armored opposition (an absurdly rare occurrence - worth treating as an outlier). It would not be unreasonable to have one or two rifles on standby, in case a situation escalates beyond what was expected.
I do not like this trend of increasing para militarization of the US police forces. You are supposed to trust a police officer. It is hard to trust someone wearing BDUs and carrying assault weapons - you are more likely to respond fearfully, which can often make things worse.
You mean like in the case where someone deceives them into thinking someone well-equipped and violent is in a certain location?
Swatting is a hard problem. We can't really put strong authentication in place because of the asymmetry of needing anyone to be able to report a violent crime in progress at any time at any location. And the anonymous report is, indeed, cause for suspicion that a crime is being committed, and if that anonymous report further claims that the bad guys are heavily armed and/or wearing body armor, that is cause for suspicion that they may indeed be telling the truth and the bad guys are ready to rock and roll at the drop of a hat.
It's a sticky situation.
Yes, there is.
The full armor, assault rifles, grenades, etc. come into play because of past situations like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Hollywood_shootout where cops had to raid gun stores for rifles because their handguns/shotguns weren't cutting it.
When there's a known/probable gunman, it's prudent to take extra precautions - larger team, better armor, weapons that'll work if the criminal's wearing his own armor. No sense getting killed in a shootout that was predictable.
If people start running around with RPGs, I'd expect reports with gunmen waving rocket launchers to be met with armored vehicles and the like.
Luckily, this doesn't seem likely.
http://www.cato.org/publications/white-paper/overkill-rise-p...
At the same time, they need to know when, where and how to use their weapons, so we reduce or eradicate unnecessary casualties.
Imagine harder. This kind of thing happens all the time.