Like I mentioned before, we do use this exact argument towards child porn, however. You cannot hurt a child by simply watching a video of child abuse. But we realized that watching the video gives incentive for people to create more, which in turn harms future children. That is a good enough reason to attempt to cease the incentive for production to prevent future occurrences.
PETA has been accused of staging content in the past, so it is not completely out of the realm of possibility that it is happening.
I imagine that the market of people willing to pay money to watch a cow be abused is significantly smaller than the market for child porn.
I hope the number of people filming crashes against random strangers on the highway are low, but crashes in a controlled environment are definitely happening to fill the market void. Heck, the demolition derby is a long standing American tradition.
> I imagine that the market of people willing to pay money to watch a cow be abused is significantly smaller than the market for child porn.
PETA makes money, and given their reach I expect significant amounts of money, from distributing such videos and similar content.
Though I would suggest that money is not the only motivator. Like I mentioned in another post, people will create content just to know people are tuning in. Likewise, in software we create and distribute free and/or open source projects just for the satisfaction of knowing others are using what we have created. Money doesn't necessarily matter.
I remember bum fights being controversial back in the day, not sure I would call it a phenomenon though. At least there the fighting was somewhat consensual such as with boxing etc.