you can replace vim with eclipse and all you said still stands valid.
vim is on pretty much every linux box. Eclipse isn't.
'The real power of vim is its proven staying power' is a non-argument, today I work on stuff that didn't even exist 10 years ago, there is no guarantee vim will be even usable for the sort of work you will be doing in a decade, and for sure there is no guarantee it will be the best choice. both vim and eclipse are here to stay for the next years and both have a lot of support.
there are lots of reasons to learn/use vim, but a 10 years longer historical consistency isn't one.
btw, I know vim is amazing. I'm arguing the arguments, not the case.