>
Like the vast vast vast majority of all consumer facing internet businesses ever created since the dawn of the Web, Google was created to do something: Search, without any clear business plan about how to make money.Without AdWords, we'd probably have gone back to AltaVista.
> Most Web businesses do not charge end user fees, they are founded to get users, and either make money from ads, or get acquired by those that do.
This is where it's confusing. AdWords behaves like old-fashioned newspaper advertising: Google both control the inventory of spots to advertise and accept the adverts.
AdSense is different: Google doesn't not provide inventory, but they fill it. In that respect they are more like a central ad buying agency than a newspaper.
> which says to me that there's some intellectual dishonesty going on, people with an axe to grind.
Or it might be that I'm just pointing out that what Google spends its money on doesn't change what people actually pay Google for.
If you classify companies according to what they are paid to do, then Google is a company that gets paid to take and display advertising, just as Ford is a company that's paid to manufacture and distribute cars or WalMart is paid to source and distribute durable and perishable retail goods.
Journalists don't like to think about where the money is coming from. And in fairness to journalists, that's been the grand bargain for more than a century: pay my wages, don't meddle too much and I'll give you good copy to sell your papers.
Well now the grand bargain is: pay my wages, don't meddle too much and I'll produce services that support, directly or indirectly, AdSense and AdWords.
There is no shame in this. None of this detracts one iota from the journalists at a media firm or the engineers at Google. But TANSTAAFL.
> Google spent nearly $7 billion on R&D in 2013.
And most of the wages paid at newspapers are not paid to the advertising or classifieds staff. They make enough money per head to support a much larger staff of journalists, designers, subeditors, setters, printers etc etc etc.
> Larry Page is not an idiot, he sees that relying on ads for 97% of your revenue is a risky proposition.
I agree. But simply elbowing your way into a different business model is hard. Really, really hard. Ask Newscorp. Ask Microsoft.