"They remain free users"? That is an option with unlimited downside for Instacart.
They could leave their accounts dormant until the users next signed in then ask them to either accept the charges or deactivate their account. That would be a lot more ethical than just going ahead and charging them and expecting them to opt out if they don't agree to the charges.
And then someone would complain that they were ambushed for an extra $99 fee right when they just wanted to order groceries...
Well the implied assumption here is that the day of the free user is over. So it's only two options - Upgrade or leave.