> Once people are reluctant to spend then, the economy will stay depressed because, people expect deflation AND deflation will continue because the economy remains depressed.
Well, if people are expecting deflation, then that expectation becomes built into the value of the currency, such that there exists an equilibrium between people expecting it to deflate further, and people expecting it do the opposite, because it's already overly valuable.
I can't see how everyone would just hoard it until there's infinite demand and zero supply, and a bitcoin has infinite value. There's always a semi-stable price.
And like I said, I don't see how the standard macroeconomic arguments apply, because right now bitcoin is just a currency "on the side", totally unable to affect economies on a large scale. And if it ever did reach that scale, governments could do things like force contracts to be denominated in some government-controlled ratio to bitcoins, so that the government would still be able to "control" the money supply, and increase or decrease it as desired. (That's just one crude example of how.)
Just because people are using bitcoins, doesn't mean that long-term contracts have to be denominated in bitcoins.
So I guess this is what confuses me about people saying that bitcoin deflation is bad. Deflation=bad arguments seem to rest on entire countries being solely dependent on a single currency, which is not the case with bitcoin. And even that became the case, it would presumably take place in a whole new way. But I still don't see anything inherently wrong with a deflationary currency, especially one used alongside "official" ones.