If your cash is increasing in value (because of deflation), then it's a smarter financial move to stuff cash under a mattress than to spend or invest it. This is why most economists think 1-5% inflation is about the sweet spot.
If your cash is increasing in value (because of deflation), then it's a smarter financial move to stuff cash under a mattress than to spend or invest it. This is why most economists think 1-5% inflation is about the sweet spot.
You need to eat to stay alive, and staying alive is more important to you than saving money, so food purchases won't be delayed very long. You don't need to play video games to stay alive, so you can wait for a couple of years to buy a video game when it becomes cheaper; some people do it to save money while other people decide that they prefer to pay more and be able to play that new video game right away (some even pay a premium if it is sold out, even though they know they could pay regular price by waiting a few days).
You don't have to buy useless things in a deflationary economy. By not spending, you have more buying power for when you do decide to spend (holding all other variables constant, which isn't real-world truth). Thus, inaction is more profitable than "useless" actions/goods/services.
In an inflationary economy, you stick money into deposits (instead of under your mattress) because you lose less that way. These deposits are used by banks to fund loans. These deposits probably guarantee a very low but fixed interest rate (such as 0.1%), which makes a tiny dent in how much you lose due to inflation. They also make the bank lots of profit when they do well and are insured against you losing any money (except by inflation, of course) as long as your deposits total <$100k.
P.S. The deposit interest rates are around 5.5% actually.
I believe this sentence.
The big problem with Bitcoin's finite money supply is that it encourages people to sit out. If there are 1000 people and someone has WLOG 1/1000th of the wealth, if they sit things out and come back 100 years later, there's no reason to think they should still have 1/1000th of the society's wealth at that point. More people were born, more resources were mined, more buildings were built, more technologies were developed -- and that person had nothing to do with it. I can see why he would wish he could still claim 1/1000th of society's wealth, but what's the incentive for all the other people to agree to this? The hope that they can be the ones to sit things out and freeride next time?
No, I don't think you'll find many economists who like deflation. It doesn't spread prosperity, it spreads laziness.
>>>It'd be stupid to put $1000 in an investment when the spending power of that money will only increase over time, and you'll never get your money back.
How do you know you'll never get it back? The entire point of investing is to make money faster than via labor or interest or prices artificially increasing (a bubble).
I think you're a little mixed up on the definitions of "inflation" and "deflation".
Nominal prices can go up while costs are going down (this is more or less what inflation is).
Putting it another way: in an inflationary economy, if the price of a good stays the same, the cost of that good is going down.
Slight inflation is good and keeps the economy healthy.
Most of the purchases we make are not to satisfy core needs, but wants. You buy slightly more expensive delicious foods instead of cheaper boring foods. You strive to live in a decent environment rather than a mud hut because the former is more pleasant than the latter. You buy things or experiences that are unnecessary to survival, but bring some form of happiness. (Research, has, however shown that buying experiences leads to greater happiness than buying tangible goods!) The list goes on. We do this in part because because we have dopamine. Eliminate dopamine and we not only struggle to feel pleasure, but our brains also stop functioning properly.
Nobody ever says it, but inflation is really a good thing because of the way our brains are wired up.
> you're just killing savings (which are the best safety net there is)
Some savings are good to smooth out the bumps in the road, but when people save too aggressively people reduce their spending and the economy also slows. When the economy slows, you're more likely to find yourself out of work and having to use those savings so you don't end up living in that mud hut!
> and inducing a misallocation of productive resources
Your conclusion is a non sequitur.
The solution to this is to meddle with interest rates or policy.
You are right that a reduction in spending/increase in savings (whatever their form) does tend to correlate with interest rates decreasing, and vice versa, but this is a deliberate decision to speed the velocity of money up again before longer-term damage happens. It's not a long-term solution. Interest rates are in many way a fiscal ballast to keep the economy properly weighted.
The trouble with Bitcoin is it's inherently deflationary. Meddling with interest rates doesn't work if your currency is Bitcoin. You also can't have a healthy amount of inflation to keep the economy growing. If Bitcoin did become a de facto currency, we'd be poorer both economically and intellectually. The latter I believe because there would be less "excess" to spend on scientific research, as typically happens in periods of economic slowdown.
Historically the best time to make an investment or start a business is in lean times (depressions are good!), but people aren't generally that rational. The value of something (currency included) is typically driven by emotions. This is why what people feel about something is everything, from a product you're selling to your currency.
A few hours ago I thought Bitcoin was awesome and a good thing, but after thinking it through and arguing this point I'm convinced it's a bad thing and will lead to a longer-term harm if it is widely adopted and begins to replace traditional currencies.
No. That is totally against the American tradition of consumer banking (at least until 1970s stagflation) as well as the way banking has been practiced in Japan. "Save it for a rainy day" didn't come from nowhere. It's what most Americans used to practice. And in Japan they are exhorted to bank as a national good to fund loans to companies. A lack of confidence in the future -- incomes remaining the same -- would empty banks of deposits.
The consumer confidence index is a measure of savings and spending. The more confident consumers are, the more people are spending and the less they're saving, and vice versa. This isn't an American thing.
What people have been taught and what people actually do are two different things.
Well, we can agree there.
Similarly, you know how we always hear that people put out of work by new technology should move up the value chain? Where they gonna move to if people aren't buying things? Wants as opposed to needs are the sign of economic progress.
Fortunately, nobody forces you to participate in deflationary currencies.
So while bitcoin is a good thing in itself, it can't replace in near future traditional currencies.
However, the more people accept Bitcoin, the more people can spend it. There will be a network effect. Eventually, if this pattern holds, the food producers will start to accept it and that's where the "trouble" occurs.
In theory, if people perceive the stability, utility, and value of Bitcoin to be greater than a traditional currency, and it starts to replace that traditional currency, the traditional currency will collapse, hyperinflation will occur, and there will be a period of pain. The late majority and laggards will lose a lot of money, and the early adopters and early majority will gain. There will simply be a redistribution based on tolerance for risk and foresight. At this stage the value of Bitcoin will soar.
Frankly, I wouldn't be surprised if governments did their best to make it illegal. Governments don't entertain competition because their role is to maintain the stability of the status quo, which is fair. We all enjoy living in a degree of stability, as opposed to a Hobbesian state of nature.