No it's not. Those things help to define a person. I don't think you entirely got the nuance that the OP was getting at.
No it's not. Those things help to define a person. I don't think you entirely got the nuance that the OP was getting at.
> No it's not. Those things help to define a person.
When you try to refute someone's position, it's expected that you will offer a counterargument, not a different topic. Yes, relationships help define a person. No, that doesn't mean the era hasn't ended in which one's relationships are central to one's identity.
You are making the same fallacy that your parent post accused another poster of making, you're failing to address to argument at hand.
Eras are defined by society at large (as much retroactively defined by future generations as defined by the present). Disregarding what society thinks refutes your entire argument. Two people caring about a certain thing is an anecdote, not an era.
Note that he never said "relationships are not worth having", merely that "The era when a man or a woman is defined by his relationships and family is over".
Your GGP's post's conclusion holds, even if what you are saying is true.
I never said that. I recommend that you argue against my positions, not yours.
> This is a ridiculous argument ...
Yes, it is -- and it is your argument, not mine.
Your argument goes downhill from there, relying on the much-revered but meaningless "who cares?" meme.
> ... it's absurd to assert that they're not worth having just because they're not preserved for all eternity.
Yes -- good thing that I didn't make that argument, only you did.
My advice is to try to stick to the content of the other person's post, rather than make something up to conveniently argue against.