Are there Vermont syrups or cheeses that have far flung demand? Perhaps a Vermont of the Month club if interest in Vermont itself is high enough.
I was considering a business of this sort, but was a bit intimidated by having to keep a large amount of products in-stock and the price that would come with that kind of thing.
I was also turned off by the lack of apparent success of a similar website: http://www.bestofvermont.com/
Any thoughts on these two concerns?
If you're serious about capitalizing on Vermont craft industries, something to consider is creating a brand. Don't sell "Vermont cheese" or "Vermont syrup"; sell "Awesome Craft Syrup (a product of Vermont)".
Look at Zingerman's in Ann Arbor, MI for an example of this business executed at its highest levels.