"Somehow you morphed that"
The three arguments against were the discussed social interaction which was pushed pretty strongly, another claimed problem was credit was not available but when it was offered students wouldn't take for-credit classes (what does that mean, if anything?) and Blivens strange quote about minds needing to be built instead of stuffed.
Based on experience in classrooms, where the usual 90:10 ratio shows 10% of the students are 90% of the interaction, and even the most biased claims showing at least a quarter of the population is introverted, that would indicate the percentage of people who prioritize social interaction must be somewhere between the two fairly ridiculous extremes, lets say 90% to 25%. However actual success rates are staggeringly worse, like single digit may as well round down to zero. So as simple engineering guess, the cause of failure simply cannot exclusively be lack of interaction. If that were the case, a more realistic failure rate would be 50% or so because probably somewhere around half the population cares about that based on examination of extreme claims.
That leaves the article with little more than the usual "we all know the correct way for humans to live is to be extroverted, and clearly radio lectures / internet lectures are not an extroverts paradise, so lets marginalize the introverts and pat ourselves on the back for figuring that out to be the failure of MOOCs, how lame of them not to cater to our talkative desires as the masters". Eh, lame.
Whatever the distance education problem is eventually correctly identified, its not going to be social interaction. Look at another technology that's completely non-interactive yet tremendously popular... watching TV.
I suspect the true answer is likely to revolve around peer pressure and motivation. No one knows or cares if I drop a class or skip a video lecture, but if it went on my permanent facebook/google record, well, maybe I'd follow up... As for motivation I would agree that if possible to attend, sitting in class might be slightly better, and its so easy to attend class "somewhere" that anyone with the slightest spec of motivation is probably already sitting in a physical classroom leaving very few motivated people left for online classes. Not no one, just very few. Now those theories could have improved the article.