It beats "This guy is wrong (source: random blog post that I didn't really read)", anyway.
Edit: To be clear, I don't love the Reddit snowclones, but there's nothing wrong with the sentiment behind "I'm a scholar in this field, and I think this guy is a hack."
I agree with the sentiment, but "properly cited" suggests a bit more than a one line comment from a username with barely a handful of posts (generally pertaining to bitcoin and intermediate level networking certifications) on an anonymous website.
>It beats "This guy is wrong (source: random blog post that I didn't really read)", anyway.
I have to disagree. At least a random blog post presents the potential for useful information or a fully articulated opinion. What we here is 4 words and an unsubstantiated appeal to authority.
Isn't the purpose of citing claims precisely so others can effectively verify or discount their validity?
Citation: a post from an anonymous Internet user who claims to have a graduate degree. Take it for what it is. What's wrong with that?
> I have to disagree. At least a random blog post presents the potential for useful information or a fully articulated opinion. What we here is 4 words and an unsubstantiated appeal to authority.
Conversely, it is far easier to engage in vigorous debate on HN than a random blog. I call it a wash.
(Besides, my read of the comment that started this was that it's quite tongue-in-cheek. He was basically saying "Don't trust this any more than any other comment you read on the Internet.")