What is the problem with DPI? It slows down torrent downloads, which are already slow, but speeds up more synchronous activity like web browsing and chatting. Don't we all want that?
The problem with DPI is that its akin to the post office reading all of your mail.
If DPI were used to allow customers to pay based on priority, would that be acceptable? For example, if you only want to pay 1 cent per GB for a torrent download that gets packets to you at 1/3 the rate of HTTP packets, which cost 2 cents per GB, would something like that work?
I am not proposing it, just continuing the post office analogy.
The article outlines some of the problems with DPI but does not make a compelling case. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_packet_inspection#Deep_Pac... for some uses of DPI at the ISP level. Each of these use cases has negative features. Those are "the problem with DPI".