I have no problem with timber companies managing their tree farms, so long as they protect water ways (offsets), slopes (no clear cuts causing mud slides), etc. I also think we need new management practices (eg permit more smallers fires to reduce likelihood of huge fires).
My problem is when timber companies must extract every board foot from every acre, threatening critical habitat, from public forests. To add insult to injury, we (the public) build the roads, and sell the timber at a loss.
I wouldn't mind so much if the mythical "free market" was working, so that timber, mining, fishing, and ranching companies actually paid fair market price for the resources they're stealing.
How is a 40 year old forest not habitat?
My problem is when timber companies must extract every board foot from every acre, threatening critical habitat, from public forests. To add insult to injury, we (the public) build the roads, and sell the timber at a loss.
Lies, lies, and more lies. Have you even been to a cut down forest within the last 20 years? Streams have required easements, there are requirements for leaving a number of trees per acre and any logging roads are paid for by the landowner. The roads are a cost of the harvesting.
...actually paid fair market price for the resources they're stealing.
You act like it's a quick turn around. We are talking decades after replanting, there are very few industries that have to follow this. And then, after waiting all that time, you need to hope that the market isn't in the state that it's currently in. Domestic timber is in the dumpster right now due to foreign logs and a lack of new housing.
Did you not read the parent's comment? 40 year old forests are not habitat because they don't come with the same ecology. It takes a very, very long time for a proper ecosystem to establish in an area. 40 years is not enough for that.
I went camping in Holland ten years ago. Almost all the forests there are second growth forests. As we were setting up our tents, my buddy stopped in his tracks and motioned at me to hush. In the silence, do you know what we heard?
Absolutely nothing.
No birds, no insects, no forest animals or any kind. It was eerily quiet. It was a forest alright, but it had no ecosystem. It was the most bizarre camping experience I've ever had.
Go into Canada and the US and camp. Railroad logged anywhere from 150 to 100 years ago, second growth logged from then on. Birds. Deer. Elk. Insects. Owls (even Spotted ones!). Fish in the streams.
The US and Canada isn't Europe. This continent has been largely undisturbed until about 300 years ago, and most of it untouched until the last 100 years. We've seen Europe's folly and fortunately didn't make the same mistakes or at least have had time to correct the problem. We also didn't have 2 world wars march across our lands, no trenches, no mustard gas.
Much of N. America from just east of the Rockies to the Pacific Ocean is amazing forests. We've made our mistakes with forestry but have atoned and things have healed up nicely. Now we manage the forests for the good of everybody - everyone can have what they want without sacrificing the quality of that resource.
Don't be so blind as to just blanket all logging in the world as 'logging bad'.
Nice.
Domestic timber is in the dumpster right now due to foreign logs and a lack of new housing.
Um, no. Timber, pulp, paper are all cyclic. Always have been, always will be.
We are talking decades after replanting, there are very few industries that have to follow this. And then, after waiting all that time, you need to hope that the market isn't in the state that it's currently in.
We're talking about public lands. What are you talking about?
I care little what timber companies do with the land we gave them last century. But if they're cutting down OUR trees on OUR land, then they have to replant that acreage. If they can't do that profitably, then too bad. There is no right to profit.
Don't be so blind as to just blanket all logging in the world as 'logging bad'.
You said it. Not me. Projection much?
You have shown you know very little of the timber industry. Private landowners are under the same laws with respect to replanting as the public lands are. Public lands are logged, sold, and the profits returned to the public in the same free market system. No matter, it ALL has to be replanted.
On what planet do you think someone is just letting perfectly good land that can support a forest just sit barren? Unless it's re-zoned into something else, that's not profitable nor sustainable. Our forests are very sustainable.
Timber, pulp, paper are all cyclic. Always have been, always will be.
If you think the pulp and paper industry will ever be what it once you are fooling yourself. In the electronic age paper is far down it's not even funny. I grew up in a pulp and paper town that is a shell of what it once was.
Blame automation. Full stop.
But look at the bright side. Twilight themed tourism is booming.
You're just plain wrong about automation, that isn't what is killing the pulp and paper mills. If that were the case the mills and the companies associated with those mills would be doing fine - just with less people. No, the mills themselves are in decline due to a lack of use for their product.
E-books, electronic documents, decline of newspapers. This isn't the 70s, this is a paperless world and only going to get more so.
It's been a while since I've looked (or cared). I've long assumed growth in pulp tracked with the economy. I didn't consider increased recycling or the economic crash (2008). Either way, I couldn't quickly find info (e.g. Wolfram Alpha).
We're talking past each other. I really don't care about the fortunes of the timber, pulp, paper industries. They've been terrible stewards of the earth. You say they've improved. Sorry, I just can't imagine that.
It's possible that the "fallow" restored forests of the northeast (mentioned upthread) are the future for elsewhere. Maybe. I don't see it in the short term. Between the pine beetle and ever greater risk of forest fires (in hindsight the bad burn mgmt as well as drying due to climate change), our forests are in trouble. To say nothing of sprawl and over development in fire prone areas...
Any way.
You really need to cut out the ad hominen. You're convinced you're right and I'm a noob. Fine. I feel you're just repeating industry misinformation. Fine. But there's no discourse when you sink to throwing around insults.
Industry misinformation or the actual laws for the states of Washington and Oregon, which follow countless other states and provinces in the Western US and Canada? You on the other hand are stuck repeating misinformation from the 80's anti-logging spotted owl rhetoric.
BTW, it's hardly an ad hominem. I'm not attacking you personally to discredit what you are saying - what you are saying is just factually wrong.
You got sideways when people (correctly) pointed out that tree farms are not the same as rain forests. Much like how a corn fields is not a wetland.
Utterly uncontroversial.
But you imagined a slight and made it personal.
Hopefully anyway.