1) A person that only does the bare minimum amount of work needed to avoid being fired exerts a cost on the economy, e.g., work place accidents due to negligence, "work shirking", taking credit for others' work through bullying and politics, etc...
2) To an extent these individuals are already using other welfare programs, e.g., social security disability payments ( see http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2011/09/how_to_be_mean_to_you... ) to this end, despite these programs not being designed with this goal in mind.
Of course this is complete a red herring in the first place: like most behavioural traits, industriousness is distributed along a normal distribution. In other words "too lazy to do any kind of work" people exist, as do people working 18 hour days, but the average individual falls somewhere in between.
Finally it's also easy to design a work around for this: even the name negative income tax hints at this -- these individuals would still receive these payments if they're working (either full time but below a living wage, or underemployed/consulting) so there's still incentive to earn more (much like a progressive income tax means there's still an incentive to earn more even once you've exceeded a certain tax bucket).
We could even make a requirement that individuals remain in the work force (even if they can't find an employer willing to hire them at this time): they would provide proof that they've applied to jobs, were seeking further education, or the like.
The fact that both liberal and Friedman/Hayek libertarian economists support this idea means there's probably something to it. In any case, the comparison is not with an ideal system, but with what with have now: on the net, a negative income tax would actually mean a smaller government and greater negative liberty (less welfare administration agencies, more individual choice and less compulsory-participation programs like an insurance mandate or social security) and it would mean those worse off in society would fare better than they do today (i.e., greater "social justice").
>We could even make a requirement that individuals remain in the work force (even if they can't find an employer willing to hire them at this time): they would provide proof that they've applied to jobs, were seeking further education, or the like.
I've long been a supporter of a negative income tax (actually, until recently it was a basic income), and this is one idea I've been trying to develop. I have some concerns about how well the idea you layed out could be implemented. It seems like it is doomed to fail due to the nessasary bueracracy. Either the process of proving you were looking for work becomes so streamline that you do not need to actually exert meaningfull effort (and possibly waste employers time to get the needed paperwork), or proving that you are seeking work would become a significant burden.
The solution I've been thinking of is some sort of work on demand program, where, while your unemployed and reiciving your guaranteed income, you can be asked to do short term work for the government (and/or private companies). Obviously this would need regulation to prevent it from being exploitative, but it would allow the governent to make more infastructure investments without needing nearly as much money. It might even save more money than we are paying people through the program as we would effectivly be getting labor at below market wages. An important part of this system is that there be no long term commitment, so if you find a job, want to move, etc, you will not be prevented from doing so. This may also require an additional investment in training the unemployed to do the specific job we need them to (but training the workforce is a good idea anyway).
Apart from the obvious regulatory issues, which seem solvable, what I can't quite figure out is how to make this fit in with a negative income tax. Effectivly the work on demand model makes the government an employer of last resort, and what would be negative income tax simply becomes a paycheck. The best solution I can come up with is abandon the negative income tax idea and embrace the government as an employer of last resort model. This sidesteps the problem of a lazy unemployed by requiring them to work to receive the income. If the 'normal' workforce gets to small employers could 'rent' these workers from the government, again at sub-market wages.
This however, risks employers not hiring 'normal' workers, but rather work on demand`ers. If this is the case, then many people would be unable to get a normal job, and effectivly be forced to work for sub-market wages, potentially leading to a situation like the industrial revolution where much of the workforce is trapped in low paying jobs because they are the only ones available.
However, because the government controls the minimum income, they control the wages of these workers, so they can increase said wages as this starts to become the case. But, as this happens we move even more into the government become the sole employer. Once this happens we begin to loose the free market, causing us to be in an effectivly socialist state. However, when a specific region of this economy becomes inneficient, an entrapanuer would have the oppurtunity to make above minimum wages by competing with the existing provider. If quality of life is good enough for everyone that no one wants to do this, then we win. If quality of life is bad enough then someone will do this. Hopefully this will allow the free market to create and maintain the proper equilibrium point between socialism and free-market.
That's been tried ("workfare") and in some case had worse effect: typical example, requiring someone to commute hours to a minimal wage job. It overrides the natural disincentive for the worker not to take this job (there net utility to them is zero) and has unintended circumstances (while I'm not a fan of Michael Moore's demagoguery, he gives a particularly strong example in Bowling for Columbine -- where a mother was left unable to participate in her son's life).
The big assumption there is that employment is intrinsically valuable, which I don't think is the case. Workforce participation is, but they two are not the same. The desire to deal with political externalities and catch "cheaters" is a very understandable one, but I think it's over-stated here. I tend to think of it in almost a reverse way: instead of trying to get beneficiaries of NNI to work by making NNI dependent on employment of some kind (even if it's just "make work" employment or rent-seeking by corportations, which this sounds like), make it such that being employed still allows one to receive NNI on top of their salary (e.g., turning a potentially below minimum wage job to a minimum wage one, turning a minimum wage job into a living wage one, turning a living wage job into a job that allows one to save).
If a citizen does ~2-4 weeks a year of reserve service (in the military or in other public-good roles), and is potentially available in emergencies (either long-term defense callups, or just public training in EMS and available as a first responder if nearby), give ~12k/yr equivalent in basic income/negative taxation.
The disabled or really useless would be another problem, but I think that's a smaller population than is currently on public or private disability.
The main advantage of a basic income/negative tax system is that you just pay people and send them one their way, you don't administer it or waste effort on bureaucracy you just accept that there is some slack in the system.
The other advantage of paying people for being trained and theoretically available is it gets around the "moral" objection to basic income unfairly paying people to do nothing.
Corvée labour is actually the oldest form of taxation. It's stunningly inefficient compared to just taking money, for all the reasons that barter is inefficient plus the resentment people have towards working for nothing.
This effectivly makes the government the employer of last resort, in the same way that it becomes the buyer of last resort to escape depressions.
It's not a substitute to normal employment, though it is certainly better than plain "sit down money". But a lot of the problems of welfare still persist anyway.
I know I'd love nothing more than to get basic income and work on open source revolutions in 3d printing, AI, computer vision, biometrics, etc. Too bad that doesn't feed me, so I have to drudge through asp.net development job ads that expect 80 hours a week from me.
> What does this mean?
A negative liberty is a term used to distinguish it from a positive liberty. A positive liberty sounds like this: "The right to free speech." A negative liberty sounds like this: "The right to not be discriminated against based on X, Y, or Z." Differently, a positive liberty is "freedom to do" whereas a negative liberty is "freedom not to have done".
So, what GP is saying is that people under such a program would make for fewer impositions on individuals by the government.
A negative right is a restriction on government that prevents it from interfearing with or punishing certain behavior. So free speech means that the government can't punish you for critizing the government. That's a negative right. So is the right to bear arms, the right to choose, the right to free exercise of religion, and the right against self incrimination.
A positive right, on the other hand, purports to create an obligation for the government. For example, the South Africa constitution guarantees its citizens basic health care. That's conceptualized as a right, they are said to have the right to health care.
Some things are tricky to place. Take the right to counsel in criminal cases. Is it a positive obligation for the government to provide an attorney or is it a restriction on what the government can do to you unless it chooses to provide you an attorney?
Descrimination is likewise tricky. Saying one has a right to be black is kind of nonsensical, allowed or not that's how people are born.
Libertarianism is defined by a focus purely on negative liberty, classical liberalism (e.g., liberal parties in Non-US Anglophone countries) has a more broad focus, and social democracy/left-liberalism (generally called just liberalism in the US, but best expounded through John Rawl's excellent work) also adds the idea of social justice.
Discrimination is indeed a challenging matter: obviously law against govenrment discrimination counts as negative liberty, but you could (and I personally would) also argue that restrictions on certain type of discrimination by individuals and businesses (in employment, housing, contracts, e.g., prohibitions on restrictive covenants for future home sales) might technically infringe on negative liberty of one group, but greatly increases positive liberty of everyone else.
There are no simple answers here and I not having a true political science, law, or economics background I would not be qualified to offer one. That's why I tried to make my appeal for NNI as broad as possible: it is clearly a policy that -- compared with what we have today and other politically viable options -- is more just no matter which one of the common political philosophies you subscribe to.
A more achievable goal is solving the idle hand problem ("idle hands do the devil's work") and preventing people from cheating the negative income tax by working off the books.
Right now, we have a problem with parasitic moochers who ruin society-- a parasitic set of nonproducers who have destroyed our values and bankrupted us. They're at the top of it.
If the worst thing that happens out of BI is that there's a class of parasites at the bottom, that I can deal with it. It improves the leverage of the productive middle against the parasitic, progress-averse top of society, and that's a really good thing.
I'm certainly inclined to agree with you. However, many of the people I've discussed this with think the middle wouldn't be so productive if their livelihood didn't depend on it. I usually argue that with automation we don't need as many people working. Imagine a machine is invented that is capable of replacing every facet of human labor. While this is obviously a great invention in our current system it would condemn the majority to insurmountable poverty. This machine is already being invented slowly. With private ownership of the means of production basic income will become a social necessity.
Most people are stuck in a mindset appropriate to a world where the most productive people are 1.25-1.50x more productive than average ones and reducing variance (bringing everyone to the middle) has expectancy.
Now, it's 10x. Everything a company does to detect and punish slackers takes several times more productivity off the best people-- who might drop from 10x to mere 4x-- than it induces gain. To quote Gus Fring, "I don't find fear to be an effective motivator".
I essentially agree. Why do we need people to be productive? Why do we need people working? We do need this, but do we really understand why? What is the moral argument derived from, that we say people must work because otherwise they're lazy?
I tried to write out an answer to these, since I have it somewhat in my head, but it's too incoherent to come out as sentences right now, so I'll just leave them here unanswered.