We're getting very far off-topic, but don't you remember the huge political battle over Obamacare?
We're getting very far off-topic, but don't you remember the huge political battle over Obamacare?
It doesn't matter. Deaths are deaths[0], and terrorism threat is pretty much neglectable in comparison with cars, murders and suicides[1].
[0] - http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Shut_up_and_multiply
[1] - http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/01/the_comparativ...
If we spent the same amount of effort reducing car fatalities, we'd have so many more saved lives.
Moreover, this is completely wrong reaction to the terrorism threat. The right reaction is to ignore it completely. Terrorism is not about blowing stuff up, it's about scaring people into changing their society and politics. By overreacting like this, America (and others) pretty much did exactly what the attacks were supposed to achieve.
By that logic, disbanding the police and court systems should bring crime to a swift and sudden end, because everyone knows that there was no crime before the creation of institutional policing.
> Terrorism is not about blowing stuff up, it's about scaring people into changing their society and politics.
Organized terrorism has a particular goal in mind, and killing people is only a particular way to achieve it. If you won't let acts of terror influence your policy, they will have to chose another way to pursue their goals.
It's a grown-up, serious version of school bullies problem; the best way to get rid of them is to either ignore them 'till they get bored, or hit them by surprise in hope they'll be so shocked to never think of attacking you again. What you don't want to do is to walk around scared and yield all the time, as this only invites more attacks.
No one said ignore the victims. The point is don't make everyone a victim by a cure worse than the attacks. 9-11 killed a few thousand. We've lost thousands by entering Iraq and Afghanistan.
We've spent a trillion dollars that if spent on heart disease treatment and research, or cancer research, or even just reducing the number of automobile related fatalities, would have saved more lives each year than we lost in 9-11.
> so I'd say your theory doesn't match up very well with events in the real world.
How can you say it doesn't match up? The terrorists changed US politics. They've made our country less free and they've drained us of a TRILLION dollars (1,000 Billion). Our country is turning into a hollywood caricature of the U.S.S.R circa 1985 -- secret police spying on citizens. These are self-inflicted wounds. We have shown there are huge rewards for terrorist action.
It's an uncomfortable but unavoidable fact that most people expect the government to protect them from things like terrorist attacks too, which is why government oaths office include a clause about protecting the United States from enemies 'both foreign and domestic.'
Those are equivalent in your mind?
Remember, for terrorists bombing and killing are only means to the end. The goal is political/social change; deaths are only collateral damage.
Basically, in this case one should shut up and multiply [0]. And [1], since we like Schneier around here.
[0] - http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Shut_up_and_multiply
[1] - http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/01/the_comparativ...
Well, I do, but only very vaguely; after all, it took place thousands of kilometers from where I happen to live and it's not like we don't have enough of our local issues to take care of.