More or less total surveillance and indefinite storage exists today.
It takes very little creativity to imagine this being abused. Choose a few keywords, and you can easily identify everyone in the U.S. with any significant civil libertarian.
Once you've got the list, all you have to do is prevent these people from getting political power, and voila, 1984.
The robot thing definitely takes more creativity to think of than that.
More generally, I tend to think that all Brute Force methods are the most crude, and a last resort even in a tyranny.