Math/pure science majors aren't worth anything. There is a huge oversupply of people with say biology or chemistry degrees. In the private sector, a biology major is lucky to start at $35k/year.
Obviously you can dramatically increase your salary by acquiring programming skills and going into software development, but that's not unique to teachers. Programmers make way more than pretty much every other field you'd find yourself in after getting a non-engineering bachelors degree, except maybe economics.
Understand, I acknowledge you might have more knowledge/experience on this, I'm just skeptical. I would think - and the tone of your argument seems to posit - that it matters more what you decide to do with that degree than what degree you have.
Is it really worthless to have a good math degree if you become a quant? I understand market oversaturation, but that could be said of almost every degree, moreso liberal arts.
But your typical teacher doesn't have a 3.8 at Dartmouth, and the option to go make $80k/year as an energy trader at a major power company. They've got a 3.4 at the local second-tier school. Recruiters at those jobs won't even read these peoples' resumes. Their alternatives to teaching are entry-level jobs at laboratories. The average starting salary of a biology/life sciences major nationwide in 2010 was $33k: http://www.forbes.com/2010/08/11/college-degrees-best-salari.... If you throw in math and physics, which pull the averages up, the average for the math/sciences category is $42k, not that much better social sciences at $37k: http://www.forbes.com/sites/susanadams/2013/04/15/college-de....