Also yes absolutely, trying to beat the cost of debt with savings isn't going to work for most people, perhaps I should have clarified my position a bit better: I think that if pensions and retirement were taught in school it would be a part of proper financial education, financial education would teach people how to properly manage money and so most people would be considering setting up a pension before they had any debt and if they did enter into debt it would be smart debt (mortgages, business loans and the like) not bad debt (to pay for a holiday or new gadget).
Although ISAs are good for saving (over not saving) the returns are negligible compared to a pension, with a pension the tax relief and potential employer contributions would greatly exceed any potential returns from an ISA. If we round up and say the limit on an ISA is £12,000 per year and the interest rate you could get on £12,000 was 3% and you're a 20% tax payer then you'd need to earn £15,000 to get £12,000 cash (after 20% income tax), then if that £12,000 sat in a 3% ISA for a year you'd earn £360 (tax free interest) making your total £££: £12,360.
If you earned £15,000 and paid it into a pension that £15,000 would never be income so it would never be subject to any tax, so already you're £3000 ahead. The tax relief on £15,000 for a 20% tax payer would be £3,000 meaning the contribution to your pension (assuming 0 employer contributions) is £18,000, 50% more than if you took the cash and put it into an ISA, after only a year! Pensions aren't ever taxed, it's only the income that is taxed once you take it at retirement, if your pension payments remained below the income tax limit (at present that's just over £10,000 for a retiree) you'd never pay a penny. ISAs and pensions are completely different in terms of what/why/when to use them but a pension is absolutely the more financially sound long term investment.
What happened to your father sucks a lot and it's definitely the case that some people did get the short end of the stick in years gone by (and it's shameful that it was allowed to happen) but fortunately pensions are now much more regulated and it's very unlikely for this sort of thing to happen again. If someone is confident that they can make better use of their money to secure their long term financial future by not paying into a pension then so be it, but for most people (in my experience at least) it's not "pension or ISA?", "pension or property investment?" it's "pension or an extra night out every week".
Pensions security information can be found here: http://www.pensionsadvisoryservice.org.uk/security-of-pensio...