I think the NSA should exist, so it is not the problem. Balancing safety and privacy is the challenge. Preventing abuse is the challenge. Having enough transparency that we are comfortable is the challenge.
Don't they do some of this already? I just think this is what they should be focusing on, rather than gathering data.
But a less abstract reply to your comment should be this: what does protecting privacy and communication mean in the case of NSA doing it, how is it done specifically and why does it make you safer?