It doesn't seem like he has put the same amount of effort in experimenting with Lisp. He doesn't mention any attempt to port Wolfenstein over to Common Lisp. Instead he seems content speculating from the same position many Lisp doubters have after reading a few books and working on some exercises (which is ironic considering his impetus for the Haskell project). I hope he gave Lisp the same treatment as Haskell before he drew any conclusions but it doesn't seem like he has from this speech.
Lisp for game development could be an interesting avenue (and has precedent in AAA console development). The dynamic vs. static argument isn't the interesting feature. Personally I think the symbolic model of computation is far more compelling. I've read posts by programmers who've written a high-level language for writing financial trading algorithms in Common Lisp that compile down to optimized VHDL for running on FPGAs. Sure you don't have a static analyzer to tell you you've done something wrong before you run your programs but I've rarely seen that becoming an issue in practice at that level. There are plenty of Common Lisp libraries that have been around for a long time that don't require much maintenance which makes me wonder where this belief that dynamic languages don't produce solid, maintainable code comes from.
In my rather limited experience I find the over-specification required by statically typed language to be a impedance to writing robust, compose-able software (at least it's much more difficult and tends to lead to Greenspunning if you try to go that route).
Either way... a very interesting talk and it's cool to hear that he's experimenting with this stuff. Carmack is in a rare position to have such a breadth of experience and deep technical knowledge that even just messing around with this stuff might make waves throughout the industry.