The problems it has are clearly discussed in multiple places -- websites, research papers, etc. I don't think it can be more sound than that.
> You're routing your data through several strangers, who are all volunteers and may be individuals who support anonymity or governments who are trying to break it, relying on them discarding logs in order to preserve your anonymity.
It doesn't matter. That is the entire idea behind Tor.
> However, there are several problems. The data coming out of the exit nodes is unencrypted. There are also lots of ways that data can leak at your endpoint. For instance, many programs may make DNS queries that don't go through Tor, so what you are looking up may be leaked.
The TBB already takes care of this. So unless you use some crappy third-party browser, you are safe from these problems because they know about it and they have been fixed.
Of course the exit node is not something you can trust. But your argument does not always hold true because TBB ships with HTTPS Everywhere by default. So almost all major websites will automatically use HTTPS and therefore the exit node sniffing your connection is rendered useless. Now if you are sending out your information over plain-HTTP, then yes, you will have it compromised.
> Furthermore, Tor doesn't sent data at a constant bitrate. Someone who can monitor traffic on a large portion of the network can correlate it across points.
Because Tor is a low-latency network, timing analysis is easy to perform if the entry and the exit node are controlled by the same entity. Now this depends on whether the NSA runs Tor exits or not and I cannot answer this question.
> Finally, due to the nature of routing traffic between several points, a fairly limited number of exit nodes, and the encryption, Tor is fairly slow. So most people won't really be able to use it on a day to day basis, making mere use of it somewhat suspicious, and likely to subject you to more scrutiny.
Anonymity loves diversity. Tor has a diverse userbase and it is getting better. I do not think it is that slow -- surely we can't expect it to be as fast as your normal internet connection -- but it is not bad either. I think FWIW, given what it does and what we need, there is no better solution so I think we might as well stick to it than trusting some proprietary software.