"by this point as a recruiter I would just not hire a person without a degree"
While the variability of self-taught is higher than those with a CS degree, there are plenty of self-taught (without CS degree) software engineers who rise to the top of hard core software engineering companies (e.g. Microsoft, Facebook, VMware etc.), besides high-profile college drop-outs like Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg.
I suspect that your recruiter position expose you to lower than average quality candidates, as most good engineers never needed a recruiter -- they are simply referred by their friends and colleagues.