The principle behind the proscription against multiple comparisons is well-known to statisticians. If we consider a 1 chance in 20 result to be statistically significant, then, randomly, on average 20 "trials" will yield one statistically significant result.
By dividing the patients into disease severity subgroups, Dr. Harkonen increased the number of "trials" from 1 to 4, thereby elevating the likelihood of yielding an effect that appeared to be statistically significant. If he also examined other subgroups in his quest to find a positive result, then he elevated the likelihood of finding a positive result toward certainty.
Our desire to find patterns and see cause and effect make us prone to confirmation bias. We can guard against this bias with care, including the use of statistics. It was not a surprise that a subsequent study looking only at the "mild-to-moderate" group did not demonstrate any benefit of the treatment. The belief that the treatment would benefit "mild-to-moderate" patients was speciously derived.