I don't think it's that simple. A 4096 bit key is extremely unlikely to get you fewer bits of security than a 2048 bit key. But the thing that makes 2048 bit keys a realistic threat is likely to make the "preference" be for something other than RSA entirely.
If 2048-bit RSA is vulnerable, then RSA is probably toast.
I know some of the CAs are using 4096-bit keys for their long term signing keys, but those are going to be in use for over a decade and are a major target. Everyone else seems to use 2048-bit.