I understand that much of the statistical analysis done is to provide as rigorous a study as is practical, however I think in some cases it misses the point slightly. The biggest issue is that the variables that drive all the analysis are ultimately almost all perception based. I'd imagine that gwern is far more in tune with his perception of things than the average person will be (a by product of doing so many double blind tests), but ultimately he's still just a human. For me, many of the variables in the study - how well I slept, my mood, my willingness to work - vary considerably day to day anyway.
Ultimately, the study found no difference. Given that we know that LSD is very active at the right doses, the only thing that you can really take away from this is that the dose wasn't high enough. Until a study has been done which yields perceptable differences, positive or negative, you can't really draw any conclusions. It's probably also fair to assume that the dose used was likely to be smaller than stated (a by product of the black market), and so the microdoses used were correspondingly reduced.