Yeah, it guarantees that only the interviewer is wasting the candidate's time. If you're hiring off the street I could possibly see some value in FizzBuzz, even though it's going to turn off any actual A player you happen to interview, but if I sent in a portfolio/past project/etc and you FizzBuzz me, I'm walking out. If you distrust a candidate that badly I can't imagine how micromanaged your employees must be.
FizzBuzz both saves you time by filtering out incompetent people, and saves actual competent people time by demonstrating that you're not willing to do what it takes to attract great hires. There's no shortcut to real interviews.