That said, there are situations where the 15" Retina 1920x1200 scaled is not as good as the 17": When I am sitting in bed (or maybe a couch), and the display is further away than it would be if I were sitting on a desk. In that situation it's not ideal, because the fonts become harder to see. But there are two potential solutions to that: If the app I am using supports zooming, just zoom the content (e.g. web browsers all do this) OR switch to the best-for-retina 1440x900 equivalent. I usually use best-for-retina when I'm not doing programming. But, I still have my 17" MBP, and it is my designated programming in bed laptop.
One of my favorite things about the Retina display is that I can arbitrarily choose resolutions without any perceived decrease in quality. This is something we had with CRTs, and didn't really have with LCDs until now.
Another potential downside: Apps that don't support the retina display look pretty terrible. They look best in scaled 1920x1200, but still not that great. The only app I use that doesn't support the retina display is Ableton Live (and it's entire UI is vector-based and can scale via a zoom setting, so you think it wouldn't be hard).