That seems wrong to me. If it's copyrighted, and they copy it the entire thing without permission, how is that not wrong?
EDIT: I see this has been discussed before many times, but this time I ask - scribd are apparently effectively immune because users upload things to them. They then claim that if it's copyrighted, it's not their fault. HN has uploaded content to them without the author's permission. Does that make HN a copyright violator?
- The site provides a legal, legitimate service (i.e. fair use)
- The amount of UGC on the site is too much to reasonably police
- They have an employee registered with the US govt as the agent for handling all copyright claims. Simply providing an email address, contact form, or even a mailing address doesn't count.
- When they receive legitimate removal requests from the copyright holders they remove the content in a timely manner.
As long as these conditions are met they can't be held liable for copyright violations which occur through the use of their product.
HN is a different case, because the amount of content copied from the source site (the headline, and only in some cases) is a small portion of the original work. Furthermore, HN is adding value to the content through ranking and community, which makes it a distinct piece of intellectual property. Similarly, you can legally make a collage which contains copyrighted material because the collage itself is a distinct entity (more than the sum of its parts).
How much of the page content can scraped and presented, or how large the pieces of a collage can be, is vividly debated. For me personally, its a bit of a Potter Stewart situation, and this feed is absolutely copyright infringement.
Actually, I might well prefer just the first paragraph and/or the top 3 three comments - I don't know yet whether I want the full articles. However, I don't think it's as cut-and-dried as you say.
These debates will continue until online publishers come up with a convenient and affordable micropayment system. I'm not opposed to advertising per se, but I am against visual the clutter it often entails. And sorry to HN designers, but the same applies to a lot of websites. Less is more.
Obviously by anyone hosting the feed for republishing full content without copy permission. I'm not happy with the current trend in copyright law, either, but it is was it is.
"I don't think it's as cut-and-dried as you say."
It really is.
Edit: your downvotes and personal opinions won't stop you from getting takedown notices and losing lawsuits. Ignore the legal reality at your own peril.
That's only if he shows up on their radar, which well, he probably won't. And if he does you just take the source he posted and run it on your local machine, which presumably would fall under fair use.
Really? But Nirmal has no way of knowing what articles people will see fit to post to HN. How can he negotiate permission with all possible content providers, given that I may link tomorrow to a brand new blog created later today?
I question whether he scan truly be said to be publishing, when it appears that the feed in question simply reformats without asserting any ownership over the content or monetizing it in any way, and involves no editorial selection on his part, something I consider a defining feature of publication.
Yes, really. And it's necessary to have a more thorough understanding of the current issues in copyright law and recognize that it's based on statutes and case law before speculating about what may or may not violate fair use. Words also already have definitions (eg, http://www.answers.com/publication and http://www.answers.com/publish) and, in a legal setting, those are the definitions you'll need to work with whether or not you have your own. I realize that this sounds somewhat ungracious (sorry! I mean no harm), but it's a legal issue, not a purely speculative philosophical issue.
Publication is the distribution of copies or phonorecords of a work to the public by sale or other transfer of ownership, or by rental, lease, or lending. The offering to distribute copies or phonorecords to a group of persons for purposes of further distribution, public performance, or public display constitutes publication. A public performance or display of a work does not of itself constitute publication.
It was this definition I had in mind when questioning whether Nirmal's feed meets the legal threshold for publication. I'm not considering his work exempt under 'fair use' tests, but rather because Nirmal's involvement here is limited to disintermediating the gap between feed reader software and end content. The lack of monetarization by Nirmal has legal significance, as does the unavailability of the content in human-readable form on his website.
I don't see where it discusses "editorial selection" which you consider to be "a defining feature of publication"
"disintermediating the gap between feed reader software and end content."
Republishing content under copyright with XML tags and an .rss extension is no different than republishing content under copyright with HTML tags and an .html extension.
"lack of monetarization by Nirmal has legal significance"
Just because a website doesn't have ads doesn't mean it's suddenly immune to copyright law. It doesn't pass any of the fair use tests, and even if it did, courts are notorious for siding with copyright holders.
"as does the unavailability of the content in human-readable form on his website"
It's just as human-readable as HTML, both raw and rendered, and modern browsers (and all RSS readers) render it just as they do HTML.
As I said, I am opposed to restrictive copyright and am devoted to CC, but copyright is what it is. If you disagree, feel free to publish a feed of full Associated Press articles, bring it to their attention and see what happens.
Before the inevitable "But I don't care!" responses, whether or not these things are interesting to us as readers is not relevant - they're still differences that could cause publishers to be unhappy and cry foul.
On the plus side, since the HN news is just an aggregation of many sources, it could encourage people to find new sources and subscribe to them directly in the long run. As a content provider myself, I'd be happy with this aggregator if it was indicated in each post what the original source is.. if that's missing, it needs to be added. We want attribution even if we're being syndicated ;-)